Search SikhNet News Archive

03/04/2008

Comments Email this Article

Sikhs have doubled their political activity in presidential races over the last election and their longtime affinity for Republicans seems to have been broken by hard work on the part of Hillary Clinton and the message of change of Barack Obama.

According to data from the Federal Election Commission, Sen. Hillary Clinton, D-N.Y., led in Sikh contributions, receiving almost $248,000 through Jan. 31. That’s more than half of the total $412,000 from 241 donors.

Sen. Barack Obama, D-Ill., was next with about $64,000. And among Republicans, former Secretary of Health and Human Services Tommy Thompson led with $24,400.

Because campaigns are not required to collect religious affiliation information, the data of more than 1.1 million records were filtered to find names containing ‘Singh’ and ‘Kaur’, and searched for 242 common Sikh surnames with typical Sikh first names.

Although the method is not perfect, the results show vivid trends in Sikh political engagement.



While Sikhs gave slightly more to President Bush than Sen. John Kerry, D-Mass., in the last election, the contributions to Democratic candidates have surged this time. Clinton has already raised more than the total $217,500 that Sikhs gave to all candidates in the entire 2004 presidential election cycle. The former First Lady has always had wide support among Sikhs who identify her with the economic prosperity the community enjoyed under President Clinton’s administration. In the Washington D.C. area, one of the largest concentrations of Sikhs, Clinton has appeared at several events and fundraisers organized by Maryland dentist Rajwant Singh, head of the Sikh Council on Religion and Education.

His first fundraiser for Clinton was in February 2006 for her Senate re-election. In June, he donated a total of $4,600 to her presidential campaign, $2,300 for the primary and $2,300 for the general election, the maximum allowed by the election commission. And when her campaign called and asked him to join, he began volunteering by making phone calls and sending emails. He is now campaigning for the March 4 primaries in Ohio and Texas. “She and her husband have always been pro Sikh-community. Anytime (we) asked for help, they have been there,” Rajwant Singh said. “We need to participate in the political process, it’s good for Sikhs and good for the country. In terms of the size and affluence of our community, we are not doing enough.” On Election Day, Feb. 12, Rajwant Singh sent an email to his “Democratic friends” asking for votes. The email referred to Clinton’s address at a Capitol Hill event in December 2001 in memory of hate-crime victim Balbir Singh Sodhi of Mesa, Ariz., who was killed shortly after the Sept. 11, 2001 attacks. And a photo of Clinton from a 2005 Sikh American heritage dinner was also included along with links to letters from the Clintons congratulating the community on various Gurpurabs (religious occasions). But despite strong Sikh financial support, Obama beat Clinton by 25 to 50 points in the Chesapeake primary. Campaign reports show that although Obama, a relative newcomer for the Sikh community, received far less than Clinton, he did raise twice as much as other long-time political friends, Thompson and New Mexico Governor Bill Richardson, combined. And his message of change has struck a chord with many Sikhs around the country, including Ravinder Singh Bhalla. A New Jersey attorney, Ravinder Singh is serving as one of a thousand policy advisors on the senator’s government-reform subcommittee. He joined the campaign at the request of Mark Alexander, Obama’s national policy advisor. The two had met while campaigning for Newark Mayor Cory Booker in 2006. Ravinder Singh said he met Obama and was impressed by his knowledge of international human rights issues. “On most issues, his policy is in line with my beliefs,” said Ravinder Singh, who has worked with Sikh clients in civil rights and hate-crime cases. Clinton’s willingness to consistently help the Sikh community is questionable, he added. Many Obama supporters have expressed concern about her lack of support on the issue of mandatory turban pat-downs at airports. When the Transportation Safety Administration changed airport security procedures regarding head coverings in August, four senators signed onto a letter to Assistant Secretary Kip Hawley, asking for justification for the new policy. Clinton was not one of them, Obama was. “It’s unfair to assume that Sen. Clinton refused to sign the letter,” said Christina Angarola, spokeswoman for Sen. Dick Durbin, D-Ill. Durbin initiated the letter at the request of the Sikh Coalition, a New York-based advocacy group. And because he had only a week to prepare and send the letter, he approached only 10 senators and received the four signatures in time. Clinton may not have known about the letter and Obama often writes letters with Durbin, Angarola said. Still, Ravinder Singh was impressed with Obama’s support. “He (Obama) never asked for money from the community,” he said. “But when the Sikh community needed support he did so without hesitation.” Ravinder Singh began fundraising and canvassing, going door-to-door asking for votes, in Iowa, New Hampshire and New Jersey. He and three others also formed a group called ‘Sikhs for Obama’ on the campaign’s Web site, which has 100 members, he said. And he plans to do phone banking, asking for votes by phone, for the Texas primary. “Fundraising is one of a number of means by which to contribute and support a campaign and draw attention to the community,” he said. Any engagement is good, no matter which party, or who wins. Valarie Kaur, another Obama supporter, has traveled to Texas to canvass in the Austin area. “It’s time to see ourselves in the American story and join,” said Kaur, a California native. Kaur said she found her voice in Obama when she heard him speak at a rally. She had felt voiceless since August 2004 when New York City police arrested her along with thousands of people protesting the Iraq war at the Republican National Convention. Kaur was there as a legal observer, but was swept up in the raid, detained and later released. Her lawsuit against the New York Police Department for physical injury and wrongful arrest is still pending. As a third-generation Sikh American, Kaur sees Obama as her best hope to change the political climate for all Americans. But perhaps her greatest personal accomplishment was realized when she convinced her life-long Republican father to become a Democrat and an Obama supporter, she said. Kaur’s father may be an anomaly among Sikh Republicans. Many of his generation, traditionally Republican, said they would remain loyal to their party’s candidate. According to campaign finance data, 49 Sikhs gave a total of more than $70,000 to GOP candidates. After Thompson, Sikhs gave $17,275 to former Massachusetts Governor Mitt Romney and $13,600 to Richardson. Gurdev Singh of Wisconsin, who made his first-time contribution of $2,300 to Thompson, said he would vote for McCain in the general election. He had donated to Thompson at the request of Darshan Singh Dhaliwal, a successful oil businessman and long-time supporter. Darshan Singh, a resident of Wisconsin since 1972, plans to vote for McCain in the general election because he is “a wonderful person” and because “Republicans are good for India,” he said. Didar Singh Bains, one of the richest farmers of northern California who immigrated to there about 50 years ago, gave $500 to Giuliani. A long-time Republican, he has contributed to both parties, but said he would vote for McCain because he is the best candidate. -By Anju Kaur Sikh News Network staff journalist [email protected]

Email the News Editor Add SikhNet news to your website


Become a SikhNet Supporter
Make a one time contribution or sign up as a monthly SikhNet donor.
History - Donation - Privacy - Help - Registration - Search


Copyright © 2007 SikhNet
Phone: 505-753-3117 - Email SikhNet Support