Previous

Next

Ask a Question

Summary of Question:	Regard To
Category:	General Sikhism
Date Posted:	Thursday, 10/23/2008 9:46 AM MDT

SSA (Sat shri Akal) Ji

This is in regard to Sikhism a religion or Panth, I have been reading many things these days about religions, races and quite confused about my religion
as there are so many things that is written in Sikh history but not in our Indian history both are contradictory some say sikhism is not a religion its a panth started by few followers like there are somany in hindus say buddhist or jains being a part of hindu religion.

So in the same way JEWS Judaism was the only religion in WEST christanity started by jesus and Islam started by prophet mohammad and people started following these religions basically both of them some how belongs to JEWISh background as Prophet mohammad was also from the tribe that roots back to JUdaism and as everybody know Jesus born in Jewish community.

If Christanity and Islam Worlds two big religions comes out of Judaism background why can't Sikhism is considered as Different religion how we can be a part of hindu religion ???

Like Jews attacked jesus At paunta sahib there were
so many Hindu and muslims kings who got together and attacked Guru ji but got defeated due to the concept of the saint soldier which says one can only be a SAint If he or she is a good warrior who can defend his or her faith ??

But the irony is Islam and Judaism rules in Middleeast and Chistanity rules
in the west Hindus rules in Asia so where Sikhism goes in india Nowhere???

What are we here for as a sikh?
And i know many Sikhs who are not in rehat maryada?
Everybody make jokes on Sikhs check one of the link
SSA (Sat shri Akal) Ji

This is in regard to Sikhism a religion or Panth, I have been reading many things these days about religions, races and quite confused about my religion
as there are so many things that is written in Sikh history but not in our Indian history both are contradictory some say sikhism is not a religion its a panth started by few followers like there are somany in hindus say buddhist or jains being a part of hindu religion.

So in the same way JEWS Judaism was the only religion in WEST christanity started by jesus and Islam started by prophet mohammad and people started following these religions basically both of them some how belongs to JEWISh background as Prophet mohammad was also from the tribe that roots back to JUdaism and as everybody know Jesus born in Jewish community.

If Christanity and Islam Worlds two big religions comes out of Judaism background why can't Sikhism is considered as Different religion how we can be a part of hindu religion ???

Like Jews attacked jesus in the same way At paunta sahib there were
so many Hindu and muslims kings who got together and attacked Guru ji but got defeated due to the concept of the saint soldier which says one can only be a SAint If he or she is a good warrior who can defend his or her faith ??

But the irony is Islam and Judaism rules in Middleeast and Chistanity rules
in the west Hindus rules on a very large part of Asia so where Sikhism goes in the world Nowhere???


What are we here for as a sikh ??????
i give a long thought on this topic but didn't get any answer

If you see Sikhs in India they have started following all the customs of
hindu religion also i am very sure in the next 50 years they will become pure hindus and the saint soldier concept As the soul of a saint and the Spirit of the warrior has gone completely.

If we loose this spirit we don't exists!!What are your views on that

Please convey my regards to Shanti kaur ji i found some of her videos on youtube beleave me whole day i have listened to her and i must say I am completely impressed by that People like you on Sikhnet really got Brains
As a Sikh i will always be proud of you,, May waheguru gives all the
strength to you for doing such a great work for the panth.

---
reply
---

Dear one,

Just meditate daily and do your nitnem and elevate yourself and others. All will come to be as planned by Akal Purkhh.

SK